The former shadow equalities minister filmed the incident, which happened in the London borough of Hackney on Sunday.
Dawn Butler, the Labour MP and former shadow equalities minister, has described being stopped by the police while driving with a friend through east London, saying her experiences show “the system is institutionally racist”.
Butler, a strong critic of police stop-and-search tactics, said the car being driven by her male friend, who like Butler is black, was pulled over by two police cars in Hackney, with officers saying the vehicle was registered in North Yorkshire.
Dawn Butler goes on to describe how, two other officers had asked the MP where she lived and where she was going, and then wrongly said the tinted windows in the back of the car were illegal, she said. It was this attitude that prompted her to go public.
I JUST GOT STOPPED BY THE POLICE DRIVING THROUGH HACKNEY… MORE DETAILS TO FOLLOW…@metpoliceuk— Dawn Butler MP✊? (@DawnButlerBrent) August 9, 2020
I recorded the whole incident.
“It makes you realise that there’s something really not right with the system,” she said. “The fact you have two bad officers, questioning me. I can come out of my house on a nice Sunday afternoon and go wherever I want to, because it’s a free country.”
Butler, who was en route to a lunch in east London, said: “My plans were basically ruined – it’s a sunny Sunday, and you don’t get many of those.”
The Brent Central MP said she was puzzled at the idea that the police computer would – wrongly – say her friend’s car was registered out of London, and that this was sufficient reason to stop them.
“That’s really interesting, because I’m doing a lot of work with the police at the moment,” she said. “It’s really important that we focus on whether the system is institutionally racist. It needs to change – it’s a bogus reason for stopping someone.”
Butler said she asked one officer why they had been stopped, and was told “there’s people who have been coming into the area”, without elaboration. Butler said she had been stopped driving her car twice while an MP, and that her friend had experienced it regularly.
She said police officers stopped her “black male friend” who was driving a “nice car” and questioned her while she was in the passenger seat.
Ms Butler told Sky News she was “angry and annoyed” by the incident, claiming the Metropolitan Police has a “cancerous” problem with institutional racism.
She said: “We were stopped because we’re two black people driving in a nice car in Hackney.
“I’m angry because I know it happens all the time every day. And people don’t know why they’ve been stopped.
In the footage recorded by Ms Butler, police officers said they were searching the area because of “gang and knife crime”.
The Metropolitan police said they were “looking into an incident” in east London but had no further information immediately.
After taking the car keys and checking the registration, the officers admitted there had been a mistake and apologised, Butler told the Guardian.
Later, the area commander for north-west London, chief supt Roy Smith, said he had spoken to Butler. He tweeted: “She has given me a very balanced account of the incident. She was positive about one officer and gave feedback on others and the stop. We are listening to those concerns and Dawn is quite entitled to raise them.”
I’ve just spoken with @DawnButlerBrent by phone. She has given me a very balanced account of the incident. She was positive about one officer & gave feedback on others & the stop. We are listening to those concerns & Dawn is quite entitled to raise them. https://t.co/q9m6SPFAvv— Chief Supt Roy Smith (@roysmithpolice) August 9, 2020
In an interview with the Guardian last week, Butler called for an end to stop-and-search tactics by police, saying the approach was racist. “It does not work, or rather, it works the way it’s designed to work. It is designed to be discriminatory,” she said.
“The fact is, where a police officer can stop a person of colour driving a car, saying: ‘We smelled drugs coming from your car; that’s why we stopped you,’ and then, when they search the car, there are no drugs, you have to ask yourself: what were they smelling?”
Butler, who served as a junior minister under Gordon Brown and was shadow women and equalities minister for Jeremy Corbyn for nearly three years, stood to be the party’s deputy leader this year but was eliminated in the first round of voting.
PLEASE HELP US KEEP GOING AD-FREEHELP US GROW.
This is a "Pay as You Feel" website.
This blog has no source of state, corporate or institutional finance whatsoever. It runs entirely on voluntary subscriptions from its readers – many of whom do not necessarily agree with every article, but welcome the alternative voice, insider information and debate.
You can have access to all of our online work for free. However if you want to support what we do, you could make a small donation to help us keep writing and staying ad-free. The choice is entirely yours.