Theresa May visited Berlin to try and save the Brexit deal. It was both a wasted trip and embarrassing to the UK
This runs down where Germany stands on the issue. It has a vested interest in avoiding a hard Brexit but an even bigger one in a strong EU.
The EU takes precedence
Together with France, Germany is the main proponent and driving force of the European Union. Thus the primary principle in Berlin’s Brexit policy has been to prioritize the welfare of the bloc. The EU, and its chief negotiator Michel Barnier, speaks on behalf of all member states collectively. Individual European nations have thus far forgone bilateral talks with the United Kingdom.
With the EU holding remarkably solid on the issue, it was always very unlikely that May would be able to extract any concessions from Chancellor Angela Merkel. After the meeting, the German leader said that negotiations
would not be reopened.
Germany’s position is identical to the EU’s that the deal agreed last month is the only one possible and should be implemented.
No cherry picking
You could buy a lot of orchards if you had a euro for every time a German politician has reassured the public that Britain will not be allowed to “cherry pick” the benefits of association with the EU without bearing any of the responsibilities.
Germany fears that if that were allowed to happen, other nations would be encouraged to quit the bloc in hopes of reaching a more favourable deal.
As Merkel has repeatedly put it “no third-party state can be better off than a member.”
The Merkel insists the backstop is needed and it appears she is the real voice of the EU
The EU has made it clear there can be no hard border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. Merkel reiterated the principle that this is non-negotiable. If that means the former stays in the customs and trade union despite being part of the UK, so be it. Merkel is all too aware of this paradox as she showed in a recent speech to business leaders.
The President of the European Commission Jean-Claude Juncker could hardly have been any clearer about the European position when he said there was “no room whatsoever” for renegotiation.
May had to undertake her whirlwind tour to show that she had left no stone unturned. But she as again left Berlin empty-handed.
She must now face the music and the British people her running to the EU and more so the German chancellor is an embarrassment to her position.
The best thing she can do for the British people is to follow her predecessor and stand down.
One of the central issues in Brexit negotiations is how much the UK will be required to pay as a “divorce bill” to settle its liabilities and obligations when it leaves the bloc. The agreement reached in November calls for Britain to fork over almost €41.5 billion ($47.2 billion). Germany will insist on this, if Britain wants a deal to leave the EU on March 29, 2019.
A secret hope?
For the time being, the official line in Berlin is that the Brexit must be “orderly” — a term that has almost displaced cherry picking as German politicians go-to cliche on the issue. But it should be remembered that Germany remains opposed to Britain leaving the EU at all. The European Court of Justice ruled Monday that Britain can unilaterally cancel the decision to leave. There may be hopes in Germany that the UK will decide to do precisely that, even if it spells the end of May’s tenure as prime minister — and even if no one would come out and say so at the moment.
Although most of the attention during the long months of Brexit talks has focused on the Frenchman Barnier, the woman from the EU most responsible for the final form of the Brexit deal is his German deputy Sabine Weyand. Bloomberg has called her “the real force behind the Brexit talks.” She undoubtedly doesn’t want all her hard work to go for nothing and likely wields considerable power behind the scenes.
Germans in the UK
Although Germany and the EU have no interest in renegotiating the deal reached in November, for a variety of reasons they don’t want Britain simply to crash out of the bloc on March 29. That, for instance, might have consequences for the 100,000 German nationals permanently residing in Britain. Under the deal, the vast majority of them would be allowed to stay in the UK, and right from the beginning of the Brexit negotiations, Merkel stressed that their fate was one of Germany’s main concerns.
Money talks, part two
Business leaders hate all the uncertainty surrounding the Brexit deal and may have the most to fear from a hard Brexit scenario. And no one stands to lose out more than German business people if that scenario comes to pass.
The UK is the fourth-largest buyer of German exports, worth almost €85.5 billion per year. Germany runs an annual trade surplus of €48.6 billion with Britain. So business representatives will be exerting pressure on Berlin to ensure that a Brexit deal, and not a hard Brexit, goes through.